Charlotte Wiley left the Catholic Church when she had a born-again experience as a young woman, and married Gary, who came from the Pilgrim Holiness tradition and felt called to be a pastor. Together, they served in a series of ministry roles, including as missionaries to Peru. Neither of them seriously considered the claims of the Catholic Church until Charlotte’s mom passed away, and attending her Catholic funeral triggered a sequence of events that began to draw first Gary, and eventually Charlotte, home to the Catholic Church.