A little while back, my eldest daughter, Lucy, was preparing to receive the Sacrament of Confirmation. In the midst of all the preparations—choosing a patron saint and a sponsor, filling out paperwork, studying her catechism lessons, etc.—she turned to me at one point and asked: “Dad, will I feel different after I am confirmed?” What followed was a good chat about the nature of the sacraments and some of the mysteries of grace and the varieties of spiritual experience. In the end though, the gist of my answer to her was: I don’t know whether you will feel different after you are confirmed, but I do believe you will be different.
Like many converts and journeyers in the Coming Home Network, coming from varied Protestant Christian theological and sacramental traditions and approaching the sacraments of the Catholic Church, my daughter asks a very natural and valid question. Part of what prompts the question about “feeling” is precisely the recognition of an incongruity between different people’s experiences as well as one’s own. Some conversion experiences are accompanied or even driven by strong emotions and a sense of God’s presence. At times, our prayers, worship, and other religious experiences come along with feelings of joy, peace, calm, and wonder.
But these are not always or even ordinarily the case. And so the question is rightly asked: Will I feel something? What should or shouldn’t I expect? What is the place of feelings and affectivity in my relationship with God?
Most of us know at least part of the answer to this question: feelings are nice, but they aren’t the measure of reality. Just because you feel something— or don’t feel something, or don’t feel the correct something—is not the ultimate measure of the truth of things. Feelings aren’t the ultimate measure as to whether God loves you and is present to you right now. They aren’t the ultimate measure as to whether Baptism raises you to new life in Jesus Christ, whether you are truly forgiven in the Confessional, or to whether you indeed have received the Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of Jesus Christ into your body in the Holy Eucharist.
We have an existential intuition that while our feelings cannot mean or be everything or even the most important thing, they cannot be and mean nothing. They too are part of the human nature God gave us, and all that God gave us is good and meaningful, even if it has been tainted by the effects of sin.
One of the effects of original sin is a fundamental dis-integration and dis-harmony among the spiritual powers and faculties that make us human. We are all familiar with our proclivity as fallen human beings to be governed by the whims of feeling and emotion—to be dependent on positive emotions, and debilitated when they are absent. We tend to feel first, choose second, and think or reason (or more accurately, “rationalize”) last.
But in the beginning it was not so. The moral journey begins and proceeds in large part by restoring the intellect and will to their governing roles over emotion. We must think before we speak or act, and not just according to how we “feel”. Following Jesus will often put us at odds with our temporary feelings and emotions in this life, calling us to challenge our fears, discipline our desires, and think, pray, act, and speak, often when we have little feeling of motivation to do so.
This struggle between our heads and hearts is part of our moral journey, but it is not our destiny. A favorite quote of mine from the Catechism of the Catholic Church can be found in the larger section on the Church’s moral theological framework, and the specific section on “the Morality of the Passions.” There we read the following:
Moral perfection consists in man’s being moved to the good not by his will alone, but also by his sensitive appetite, as in the words of the psalm: “My heart and flesh sing for joy to the living God.”
When we talk about salvation as Catholics, we don’t just mean “getting into heaven on a technicality.” We precisely mean God’s gift of our total conversion, healing, sanctification, and perfection as human beings—a transformation in Jesus Christ which will allow us to enter into perfect communion with the Holy Trinity. What the Church proposes in the quote above, is that this sanctification in Christ will not just mean the perfection of our intellect and will, but our “feelings” as well. Not only will our minds be fully opened and conformed to truth, and our wills fully conformed to goodness, but our hearts—our feelings, passions, our affective core—these too will be beautifully conformed to the reality of things. We will “feel” the way we ought to feel in response to God’s truth, goodness, and beauty.
This Catholic vision of the restoration and perfection of our human nature to which we are destined is a beautiful one, and I think it can help us to make more sense of our own experience of the brokenness of sin and the variety and variability of the role of emotions in religious experience—and how the sacraments truly are a key to our healing.
In the sacraments, God promises that He will show up, that His grace will be at work in us—even and especially in ways and depths that we will neither perceive nor feel in the moment. The sacraments are our spiritual medicine offered to us by the Divine Physician. We need the medicine, but we also need to come to know, trust, and love—and indeed to obey—the physician, even when we don’t “feel” like it. By God’s grace, when we choose to trust and obey Him, He continues the healing and sanctifying process within us—enlightening our minds, purifying our wills, and I believe in the end, conforming also our hearts—our emotions and passions—to that of the Most Sacred Heart of Jesus.
So a different way to answer the question “Will I feel different?” might be this: Yes. Yes you will feel different. Perhaps not at the moment of your confirmation (or baptism, reconciliation, or first holy communion). Perhaps not every time you choose to pray, worship, or carry out the good works God has called you to do. But you will—in the end, by God’s grace—feel, not just different, but right. In the end your heart will sing with joy to the living God.
O Jesus, meek and humble of heart, make my heart like unto thine.





